Alcohol Consumption by country. | Main | Google Image Word of the Day - nuclear explosion

August 16, 2004

Gilmore v. Ashcroft

081604_gilmore_v_ashcroft.PNG

On the 4th of July 2002, John Gilmore, American
citizen, decided to take a trip from one part of
the United States of America to another. He went
to Oakland International Airport -- ticket in hand
-- and was told he had to produce his ID if he
wanted to travel. He asked to see the law demanding
he show his 'papers' and was told after a time that
the law was secret and no, he wouldn't be allowed
to read it.
He hasn't flown in his own country since.

I am a strong Bush supporter but this is an area
that I disagree with the direction of his politics.
I think that requesting ID for travel purposes and
a national ID system may be two of the most dangerous
and damaging things occurring in the USA. I hope
that the Supreme Court has the foresight to see how
dangerous this is and strike it down.
-ritilan

link (via boingboing)

Posted by ritilan at August 16, 2004 01:56 PM

Trackback Pings

TrackBack URL for this entry:
/cgi-bin/mt/mt-tb.cgi/658

Comments

OK Rit..... let me clear something up. I do not support a national ID system. But comparing it to the Nazi's system is a bit extreme. I do not believe the purpose of the national ID system is to "wipe out" all americans. Be careful, you are starting to sound like a damn democrap!

What I do support is my family's safety. I will gladly show my driver's lisence to anyone if it means that my children will be in a safer place.

Posted by: Goat Boy [TypeKey Profile Page] at August 17, 2004 07:49 AM

Sorry GoatBoy I am going to have to disagree with you on this one. It is true that it is not a large imposition to allow the checking of Id's for travel but It is where it leads too. By saying if you have done nothing wrong then you have nothing to worry about is misleading. The Jews in Nazi Germany had done nothing wrong but a national ID system was used to try and systematically wipe them out. By having to show ID we are negating the whole premise of Innocent until proved guilty. If I must show ID then I am guilty by default and am having to prove to the government agent that I am not lying about who I am. It is all the small freedoms that we give away that will get us in the end. They had to show ID to travel in communist Russia and still in communist China we should not in a free America.

-ritilan

Posted by: ritilan [TypeKey Profile Page] at August 16, 2004 05:05 PM

Were the Founding Fathers criminals trying to protect themselves when they inserted the 4th and 5th amendments into the Bill of Rights?  After all, nobody who hasn't done anything wrong needs to worry about being searched or being forced to testify against himself.

Posted by: cypherpunks [TypeKey Profile Page] at August 16, 2004 04:13 PM

Why not show ID? If you have nothing to hide, I do not see what the big deal is. Thats like not wanting to show ID when cashing a check or when getting pulled over. I have other stuff to worry about than flashing my ID to get on a airplane. And if some jack off is holding up the line in an already overcrowded airport because he refuses to show his ID, than push him aside and let me ahead of him, with ID in hand!

Posted by: Goat Boy [TypeKey Profile Page] at August 16, 2004 03:52 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?

(you may use HTML tags for style)